To What Extent Are Large Language Models Capable of Generating Substantial Reflections for Motivational Interviewing Counseling Chatbots? A Human Evaluation

Erkan Basar, Iris Hendrickx, Emiel Krahmer, Gert-Jan Bruijn, Tibor Bosse


Abstract
Motivational Interviewing is a counselling style that requires skillful usage of reflective listening and engaging in conversations about sensitive and personal subjects. In this paper, we investigate to what extent we can use generative large language models in motivational interviewing chatbots to generate precise and variable reflections on user responses. We conduct a two-step human evaluation where we first independently assess the generated reflections based on four criteria essential to health counseling; appropriateness, specificity, naturalness, and engagement. In the second step, we compare the overall quality of generated and human-authored reflections via a ranking evaluation. We use GPT-4, BLOOM, and FLAN-T5 models to generate motivational interviewing reflections, based on real conversational data collected via chatbots designed to provide support for smoking cessation and sexual health. We discover that GPT-4 can produce reflections of a quality comparable to human-authored reflections. Finally, we conclude that large language models have the potential to enhance and expand reflections in predetermined health counseling chatbots, but a comprehensive manual review is advised.
Anthology ID:
2024.hucllm-1.4
Volume:
Proceedings of the 1st Human-Centered Large Language Modeling Workshop
Month:
August
Year:
2024
Address:
TBD
Editors:
Nikita Soni, Lucie Flek, Ashish Sharma, Diyi Yang, Sara Hooker, H. Andrew Schwartz
Venues:
HuCLLM | WS
SIG:
Publisher:
ACL
Note:
Pages:
41–52
Language:
URL:
https://aclanthology.org/2024.hucllm-1.4
DOI:
Bibkey:
Cite (ACL):
Erkan Basar, Iris Hendrickx, Emiel Krahmer, Gert-Jan Bruijn, and Tibor Bosse. 2024. To What Extent Are Large Language Models Capable of Generating Substantial Reflections for Motivational Interviewing Counseling Chatbots? A Human Evaluation. In Proceedings of the 1st Human-Centered Large Language Modeling Workshop, pages 41–52, TBD. ACL.
Cite (Informal):
To What Extent Are Large Language Models Capable of Generating Substantial Reflections for Motivational Interviewing Counseling Chatbots? A Human Evaluation (Basar et al., HuCLLM-WS 2024)
Copy Citation:
PDF:
https://aclanthology.org/2024.hucllm-1.4.pdf