Speech Language Models in Low-Resource Settings: Performance, Evaluation, and Bias Analysis (2026)


up

pdf (full)
bib (full)
Proceedings of Speech Language Models in Low-Resource Settings: Performance, Evaluation, and Bias Analysis (SPEAKABLE) @ LREC 2026

Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) has significantly transformed human-computer-interaction and natural language processing. However, many African spoken languages, including Efik, remain severely underrepresented in ASR research. This paper investigates the adoption of state-of-the-art foundational ASR models such as XLS-R and Whisper through fine-tuning for Efik, a low-resource tonal language and empirically evaluates their performance. We curate a 3-hour Efik speech dataset and conduct a comparative evaluation using standard ASR metrics. We further augmented the XLS-R CTC model with a 3-gram KenLM language model trained on an Efik text corpus. Experimental results show that XLS-R-300M + KenLM achieves a word error rate (WER) of 10.86% and a character error rate (CER) of 3.16%, substantially outperforming both the baseline XLS-R (WER: 29.2%, CER: 6.4%) and Whisper across noisy and multi-speaker conditions. These findings suggest that lightweight CTC models augmented with language model integration offer a more robust and practical approach for extremely low-resource tonal languages than larger sequence-to-sequence models.
While modern Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems achieve high accuracy on benchmark corpora, their performance often degrades when there is real-world variability. This work focuses on variability arising due to accented, spontaneous, and domain-specific speech. In particular, we introduce PAper REading DAtaset (PAREDA), a first-of-its-kind multi-accent speech dataset consisting of discussions on academic Natural Language Processing (NLP) papers between speakers with Australian, Indian-English, and Chinese English accents. Each session elicits a spontaneous monologue (a summary of a paper’s abstract) and a non-monologue (a question-and-answer session between participants), resulting in a corpus rich with technical jargon and conversational phenomena. We evaluate the performance of SOTA ASR models on PAREDA, analysing the impact of accent mixing and increased speech rate. Our results show that, in the zero-shot setting, models perform worse, confirming the dataset’s challenging nature. However, fine-tuning on PAREDA significantly reduces the Word Error Rate (WER), demonstrating that our dataset captures linguistic characteristics often missing from existing corpora. PAREDA serves as a valuable new resource for building and evaluating more robust and inclusive ASR systems for specialised, real-world applications.
This study investigates how Whisper handles interactional phenomena in spontaneous Italian conversation, focusing on backchannels, repairs, and filled pauses. We compare standard Word Error Rate (WER) optimization with a decoding strategy that explicitly rewards the preservation of interactional events. Results show that decoding choices have limited impact on overall accuracy, while recognition remains strongly phenomenon-dependent, suggesting structural limitations in the handling of interactional phenomena, with systematic linearization of repairs and frequent suppression of short conversational items.
Word Error Rate (WER) remains the standard metric in automatic speech recognition (ASR) evaluation, yet it does not capture higher-level linguistic distinctions such as prosody. This article examines how three state-of-the-art open-source ASR models (Whisper, Meta’s MMS, and GigaAM) handle the distinction between Russian polar questions and assertions. Russian is particularly suitable for this investigation because polar questions can be marked either morphologically (li, razve) or purely intonationally, without changes in word order. Using audio stimuli from a controlled psycholinguistic experiment, I compare human classification performance in two experimental studies with ASR transcriptions, taking sentence-final punctuation as a proxy for prosodic interpretation. While human participants show near-ceiling accuracy, the ASR models perform inconsistently, especially on intonationally marked questions. Additional contextual cues improve performance in some cases but also reveal instability across conditions. The results demonstrate that evaluating punctuation provides insights beyond WER and allows a more fine-grained view of how current ASR systems encode prosodic and grammatical information.
Large speech recognition models like OpenAI’s Whisper achieve high accuracy but are difficult to deploy in resource-constrained environments due to their high memory and computational demands. This matters for low-resource and on-device settings, where compute and memory constraints often limit the practical use and evaluation of ASR systems. To address this, we present a unified, cross-library evaluation of post-training quantization (PTQ) on Whisper-small, comparing supported configurations across quantization scheme, method, granularity, and bit-width. Our study is based on four libraries—PyTorch, Optimum-Quanto, HQQ, and bitsandbytes. Experiments on LibriSpeech test-clean and test-other show that dynamic int8 quantization with Optimum-Quanto offers the best trade-off, reducing model size by 57% while lowering Word Error Rate below the baseline. Additional experiments on Whisper-base and Whisper-tiny confirm these trends, though with more pronounced degradation at lower bit-widths. Static quantization performed worse, likely due to the absence of efficient low-bit implementations for operations such as LayerNorm and Softmax. More aggressive formats (e.g., nf4, int3) achieved up to 71% compression at the cost of accuracy in acoustically challenging conditions. Our results demonstrate that carefully chosen PTQ methods can substantially reduce model size and inference cost without retraining, enabling efficient deployment of Whisper on constrained hardware.
Voice-based interfaces are widely used; however, achieving fair Wake-up Word detection across diverse speaker populations remains a critical challenge due to persistent demographic biases. This study evaluates the effectiveness of demographics-agnostic training techniques in mitigating performance disparities among speakers of varying sex, age, and accent. We utilize the OK Aura database for our experiments, employing a training methodology that excludes demographic labels, which are reserved for evaluation purposes. We explore (i) data augmentation techniques to enhance model generalization and (ii) Knowledge Distillation of pre-trained foundational speech models. The experimental results indicate that these demographics-agnostic training techniques markedly reduce demographic bias, leading to a more equitable performance profile across different speaker groups. Specifically, one of the evaluated techniques achieves a Predictive Disparity reduction of 39.94% for sex, 83.65% for age, and 40.48% for accent when compared to the baseline. This study highlights the effectiveness of label-agnostic methodologies in fostering fairness in Wake-up Word detection.
Speech Large Language Models have recently enabled the processing of spoken language by coupling powerful language models (LLMs) with pre-trained speech encoders. However, their multilingual scalability remains limited, particularly for low - resource and unseen languages, while naïve fine- tuning often triggers catastrophic forgetting of previously learned languages. This work investigates how Continual Learning (CL) can be used to sustainably expand multilingual Speech LLMs. We first demonstrate that multilingual projectors can be efficiently bootstrapped to new languages , even with extremely small datasets, but at the cost of severe degradation on the original supported languages. To address this, we adopt rehearsal-based CL strategies and show that interleaving even small amounts of replay data effectively stabilizes multilingual performance. Through extensive ablations, we quantify the minimum rehearsal budget required to prevent forgetting and identify fragile languages that require more targeted reinforcement. We further evaluate sequential acquisition of four linguistically diverse languages (Ukrainian, Japanese, Thai, and Vietnamese), revealing the trade -offs between buffer size and long- term stability. Finally, based on these empirical observations, we propose a Fragility-Based Sampling heuristic as a pathway to allocate rehearsal data more efficiently by tiering languages according to their stability thresholds. Our findings provide a practical roadmap for scalable, resource-efficient multilingual expansion of Speech LLMs, enabling inclusive ASR systems that can grow over time without sacrificing prior knowledge.
Many studies have shown automatic speech processing (ASR) systems have unequal performance across speaker groups (SG’s). However, the manner in which such studies arrive at this conclusion is inconsistent. To pave the way for more reliable results in future studies, we lay out best practices for benchmarking ASR fairness based on literature from machine learning fairness, social sciences, and speech science. We then perform a case study on the Fair-speech benchmark, applying aforementioned best practices, and discuss how failing to do so can result in erroneous conclusions. On the whole, we advocate for as fine-grained an analysis as possible, taking into account as many variables as are available, in order to eschew dataset-level bias.
Automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems often exhibit uneven performance across accents, raising concerns about fairness and bias. This study investigates the impact of model fine-tuning strategies on ASR performance and accent-related disparities. We conduct a controlled empirical evaluation of two adaptation approaches—single-step and two-step fine-tuning—using pretrained Whisper (small) and Wav2Vec2-XLSR-53 models on African-accented English speech from the AfriSpeech-200 dataset, covering Yoruba, Igbo, Swahili, and Hausa accents. Both fine-tuning strategies substantially reduced mean word error rate (WER) for all models. However, these improvements did not translate into consistent reductions in accent-related performance gaps. When analysed separately across general and clinical subsets, WER gaps often increased due to uneven gains across accents. Although two-step fine-tuning provided modest improvements over single-step adaptation, its impact on reducing disparities remained limited. These findings indicate that fine-tuning primarily optimises performance without effectively addressing systematic bias across speaker groups, even when models are specialised for individual accents. This highlights the limitations of per-accent specialisation as a practical bias mitigation strategy.
Speech variation between native and non-native speakers of French is addressed with a low-resource method based on a frame-wise comparison of wav2vec2 acoustic embeddings, using fine-grained phonetic transcriptions by expert annotators as baseline. z-normalisation and t-normalisation are explored to assess what the embeddings contain in terms of phonetically analysable information. We explore non-supervised methods for solving basic speech-related research questions. Adapting Dynamic Time Warping to speech embeddings, we compare phonologically similar recordings of sentences read-aloud by native vs. non-native speakers of French. The question is whether XLSR-53 embeddings are more robust than MFCCs to inter-speaker vs. intra-speaker variability for same words. Then we investigate whether native speaker productions are more stable than those of non-native speakers. Results suggest that the model allows phonetically meaningful correlative analyses. Working on the raw embeddings shows however that the representations are not speaker-independent, so with a view to address issues in relationship with L2 pronunciation variability, we show that t-normalisation brings us a way to separate fluency and accuracy effects in L2-speech. This shows that wav2vec2 encapsulates time-dependent phonetic information in the embeddings, including speaker accent which can not easily be disentangled from speaker ID.
This study investigates the ability of speech-based language identification (LID) systems to handle dialectal variation in low-resource settings and explores whether classification outcomes correspond to phonetic proximity and can serve as an exploratory tool for dataset quality. We collected corpora for three macrolanguages Mande, Quechuan, and Yiddish, each presenting distinct internal variation, and evaluated three types of models: GMM, Whisper, and Wav2vec2-based architectures. Models were tested both within language families and across the entire multilingual dataset to assess generalization. Layer-wise classifiers built on wav2vec2-XLSR embeddings were used to identify the layers most sensitive to phonetic or phonological features. Results show that simple GMM models can generalize well in small, highly similar datasets, while Whisper-based classifiers tend to overfit, particularly on closely related dialects. Wav2vec2-XLSR (layer 12 + MLP) captures better fine phonetic and prosodic distinctions, suggesting that embeddings encode nuanced pronunciation cues. For datasets with more diverse sources like Quechua, Whisper demonstrates better generalization. Overall, LID classifiers can both reveal linguistic patterns and highlight dataset quality issues, with model architecture and layer-specific representations shaping performance.
Large self-supervised speech (SSL) models achieve strong downstream performance, but their size limits deployment in resource-constrained settings. We present HArnESS, an Arabic-centric self-supervised speech model family trained from scratch with iterative self-distillation, together with lightweight student variants that offer strong accuracy-efficiency trade-offs on Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR), Dialect Identification (DID), and Speech Emotion Recognition (SER). Our approach begins with a large bilingual Arabic-English teacher and progressively distills its knowledge into compressed student models while preserving Arabic-relevant acoustic and paralinguistic representations. We further study PCA-based compression of the teacher supervision signal to better match the capacity of shallow and thin students. Compared with HuBERT and XLS-R, HArnESS consistently improves performance on Arabic downstream tasks, while the compressed models remain competitive under substantial structural reduction. These results position HArnESS as a practical and accessible Arabic-centric SSL foundation for real-world speech applications.
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) evaluation has traditionally relied on Word Error Rate (WER), a metric that treats all errors equally and obscures critical failure modes. In this paper, we present a fine-grained human evaluation of Meta’s recently released OmniASR system on Saudi Arabic dialects using the SADA dataset. Three trained annotators evaluated 103 audio samples, producing 264 annotations across two dimensions (comprehensibility and naturalness) while categorizing errors using a novel 10-category Arabic-specific error taxonomy. OmniASR achieved a mean WER of 42.2% and mean comprehensibility of 3.62/5, but exhibited a bimodal performance pattern: 32.6% of transcriptions achieved perfect scores while 21.2% were essentially unusable. Error analysis reveals that hallucinations and deletions have the greatest negative impact on comprehensibility (−1.64 and −1.57 points respectively), roughly 6× more damaging than named entity errors. Importantly, WER correlates only moderately with human comprehensibility ratings (r = −0.679), explaining just 46% of variance in human judgments. These findings demonstrate the limitations of WER as a sole evaluation metric and highlight the need for human-centered, error-type-aware evaluation frameworks for Arabic ASR systems.
Multi-modal Speech Language Models (SpeechLMs) are a recent advancement in natural language processing. These SpeechLMs are instruction-tuned and optimized for general tasks. Their usefulness for Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR), particularly in relatively low-resource scenarios, remains largely understudied. This work developed SpeechLM for ASR in Basque and Maltese and studied the impact of language-adapted Large Language Model (LLM) and speech encoder within the SpeechLM for ASR. Using supervised learning, we fine-tuned LLaMA-Omni, a SpeechLM, for ASR. We have conducted comprehensive hyperparameter tuning and experimented with language-adapted SpeechLM components to improve performance and evaluated our best models on in-distribution datasets for both languages and an out-of-distribution dataset for Basque. LLaMA-Omni achieved 8.09% WER in Basque and 25.65% WER for Maltese on average across multiple test splits. The in-distribution results show that SpeechLM outperforms a fine-tuned ASR system under specific constraints, whereas it underperforms the baseline model on out-of-distribution Basque, indicating weaker overall robustness. We also find that a language-adapted LLM within SpeechLM improves in out-of-distribution settings when compared to the off-the-shelf LLM within SpeechLM.
This study explores how bilingual fine-tuning affects automatic speech recognition (ASR) in low-resource languages. We evaluate this method across nine linguistically and geographically diverse language pairs, covering a range of language families and writing systems. To distinguish the two languages, during training, we pre-pend each input text with a language identification token. At inference, the model jointly predicts both the language and transcription from the speech input alone. As texts for which the language is incorrectly determined show low ASR performance, we also conduct a follow-up experiment in which the language identification token is provided both during training and inference. Our results show that bilingual fine-tuning can be beneficial when language identification accuracy is high, and that in cases where language identification performance is low, including the language identification token at inference helps to improve ASR performance.
This study presents our attempt on applying Query by Example - Spoken Term Detection methodologies to a real-world, low-resource scenario: building an audio-based query functionality for the diasporan Teochew dictionary WhatTCSay. This functionality enables users to retrieve dictionary entries without prior knowledge of the writing systems in Teochew, thereby enhancing the accessibility of the dictionary and facilitating language revitalization efforts within Teochew communities. To address the retrieval task, we investigate two approaches: (i) an ASR-based approach using text-to-text matching, and (ii) a Dynamic Time Warping (DTW)-based acoustic framework for audio-to-audio retrieval. In the first approach, we compare an automatic romanization of the spoken query against the gold romanization from the dictionary; in the second, we directly match the user’s spoken query against audio recordings from the dictionary pronounced by a native speaker. Retrieval performance is evaluated using recall at rank k. Results show that text-to-text matching achieves better performance than audio-to-audio matching; however, the two approaches were not optimized under fully comparable conditions, as the ASR-based approach benefited from additional optimization, which was not equally available for the DTW method.
Automatic speech recognition (ASR) for low-resource languages remains challenging due to limited labeled data. Although multilingual models and the inclusion of related auxiliary languages enable cross-lingual transfer, it is still unclear how introducing cross-lingual information at different training stages-pre-training versus fine-tuning-affects downstream performance. Prior work largely treats transfer as a single-stage optimization problem without disentangling stage effects. We present a stage-aware analysis of cross-lingual transfer for Faroese ASR using related auxiliary languages and Wav2Vec 2.0 XLS-R models. We systematically compare two complementary adaptation pipelines: (i) cross-lingual supervised fine-tuning and (ii) cross-lingual continuous pre-training prior to fine-tuning. Both strategies are evaluated under a unified setup with controlled model architectures, balanced representation of auxiliary languages, and identical evaluation protocols. Results demonstrate that cross-lingual transfer is stage-dependent. Supervised adaptation optimizes in-domain accuracy, while pretraining-level adaptation enhances robustness and reduces Character Error Rate (CER). Auxiliary language effects vary across pipelines, reinforcing the idea that transfer effectiveness depends on when and how cross-lingual information is introduced. Comparisons with large-scale multilingual ASR models highlight trade-offs between model scale and explicit, small-scale domain-aware adaptation. These findings suggest that effective cross-lingual transfer for Faroese low-resource ASR is inherently stage-dependent rather than a single-step design choice.
In recent years, there has been an upsurge in research on automatic speech recognition (ASR) for low-resource languages. Particularly, transfer learning using multi-lingual models has become a popular remedy for the lack of available datasets for target languages. However, given the complexities associated with each individual language, we argue it is unlikely that a single multi-lingual pre-training model will provide equal performance gains across all languages. We also recognise the important, and insufficiently studied influence that the specific pre-training dataset has on the performance of the model. In this paper, using the Irish language as a case study, we propose a more directed, incremental form of pre-training which we term multi-step fine-tuning. This method accounts for the complex relationships between the language and dataset features of the source pre-training and target datasets. We show multi-step fine-tuning improves performance over simple multi-lingual fine-tuning alone, and we investigate factors leading to certain pre-trained models achieving better results through linguistic and dataset similarity measures. This research also investigates the uniformity of the performance gains across different demographics. We show that the optimal pre-training strategy can differ between demographics suggesting that more careful pre-training dataset selection is necessary to ensure equitable outcomes in practice.
We present a blank-aware decoding approach for transcript-free phoneme alignment with CTC-based speech foundation models, designed to improve annotation bootstrapping in low-resource languages. While CTC models provide frame-level phoneme posteriors without requiring transcripts, greedy decoding produces blank-dominated and temporally unstable segmentations that are difficult to correct manually. Our approach introduces two training-free blank-resolution strategies operating directly on CTC logits: (i) confidence-ratio substitution, which promotes competitive non-blank hypotheses relative to the blank symbol, and (ii) recursive context adjustment, which enforces local contextual consistency within blank spans. Experiments on English (TIMIT) and on Sardinian and Tyrolean dialect corpora show consistent improvements in boundary F1 prediction, phoneme duration regularity, and segmentation stability over greedy CTC decoding. Although absolute boundary deviations remain higher than transcript-conditioned aligners, the resulting alignments are structurally coherent and suitable for manual correction. A post-hoc phoneme-class analysis further reveals systematic asymmetries in blank resolution, highlighting complementary roles of local acoustic evidence and contextual cues, and outlining prominising venues for future improvements.
Automatic speech recognition (ASR) has advanced rapidly in recent years, driven by large-scale pretrained models and end-to-end architectures such as SLAM-ASR. A key component of SLAM-ASR systems is the Whisper speech encoder, which provides robust acoustic representations. While model pruning has been explored for the full Whisper encoder–decoder architecture, its impact within the SLAM-ASR setting remains under-investigated. In this work, we analyze the effects of layer pruning in the Whisper encoder when used as the acoustic backbone of SLAM-ASR. We further examine the extent to which LoRA-based fine-tuning can recover performance degradation caused by pruning. Experiments conducted across three Whisper variants (Small, Medium, Large-v2), three languages representing distinct resource levels (Danish, Dutch, English), and over 200 training runs demonstrate that pruning two encoder layers causes only 2–4% WER degradation, and that combining this pruning with LoRA adaptation consistently outperforms the unpruned baseline while reducing total parameters by 7–14%. Moreover, our error analysis reveals that LoRA primarily compensates through the language model’s linguistic priors, reducing total word errors by 18.2%, with substitution errors showing the largest reduction. However, for low-resource Danish, LoRA introduces increased insertion errors, indicating that compensation effectiveness depends on the LLM’s pre-existing language proficiency and available training data.
This paper introduces the TaLK Corpus, the first speech benchmark corpus for Sri Lankan Tamil Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) covering speech from 22 administrative districts of Sri Lanka. The corpus contains 1 hour and 33 minutes of speech from 22 native speakers (one per district) and includes rich metadata on demographics, location history, recording conditions, and domain information, along with transcriptions in Tamil script and the International Phonetic Alphabet (IPA). Standardised preprocessing (16 kHz mono WAV format) and segmentation using Silero Voice Activity Detection (VAD) resulted in 1,214 utterances. All recordings were manually transcribed by trained linguists, and MD5-based file naming used to ensure data integrity and consistency. TaLK corpus enables district-wise benchmarking of ASR systems and supports dialect-sensitive evaluation. We establish baseline results for multilingual models (Whisper Large-V3 and Facebook’s MMS) in zero-shot settings. The evaluation reveals substantial performance disparities across districts, highlighting the impact of regional phonological variation in low-resource Sri Lankan Tamil. Although Whisper Large-V3 outperforms MMS overall, it shows considerable variability, with mean Word Error Rates ranging from 0.672 to 0.903 across districts. These findings demonstrate strong regional effects even within a single model. By releasing TaLK-Corpus under the CC-BY-NC 4.0 licence, we aim to support dialect-robust ASR research and foster inclusive speech technologies for Sri Lankan Tamil-speaking communities.