Bolin Shen

Author directory

2026

Rubric-based text evaluation increasingly relies on large language models (LLMs) as scalable judges, yet frozen black-box models can interpret the same criteria inconsistently, produce score attributions that are difficult to audit, and map judgments poorly onto human scoring scales. We define this challenge as criteria transfer: translating human rubric intent into a stable, auditable inference-time scoring protocol. We introduce RULERS, which locks a task-level rubric specification, executes it through structured, evidence-grounded judgments, and calibrates the resulting signals to human score boundaries. Across four rubric-governed benchmarks and multiple frozen backbone models, RULERS achieves stronger agreement with human scores in most evaluated settings, while better matching empirical score distributions and remaining more stable under semantically equivalent rubric perturbations. Calibration controls and component ablations show that these gains cannot be attributed to post-hoc alignment alone, but depend on the combination of fixed criteria, traceable evidence, and calibrated score interpretation. These findings suggest that reliable LLM judging requires faithfully operationalizing human evaluation standards rather than relying on prompt-level scoring alone. Our code is available at https://github.com/LabRAI/Rulers.git.

2025

Large language models (LLMs) hold promise for advancing patient–provider communication, yet a persistent gap remains between benchmark-driven model development and the realities of clinical practice. This work presents a systematic, clinically grounded review of text-based medical datasets for LLM training and evaluation. We propose a scenario-based taxonomy derived from established clinical frameworks to map major knowledge-based and conversation-based corpora against core communication scenarios. We further synthesize core communication skills from gold-standard clinical assessment instruments and meta-analyze state-of-the-art medical LLM performance, highlighting how dataset properties, fine-tuning strategies, and evaluation metrics shape both knowledge acquisition and communicative competence. To empirically validate these findings, we conducted controlled fine-tuning experiments across representative LLMs, demonstrating that data composition and scenario alignment critically affect model performance. Our findings highlight the urgent need for scenario-rich datasets and standardized, human-centered evaluation protocol to advance clinically relevant medical LLMs.