Automatic metrics are widely used to evaluate text quality across various natural language processing tasks. Despite their convenience and scalability, the extent to which these metrics reliably reflect textual quality remains an open challenge. The LLM-as-a-judge paradigm has recently emerged, aligning more closely with human judgments by using LLMs themselves as evaluators. However, there is still a gap in such evaluations across specific domains and languages, as most prior work focuses on generic task benchmarks in English. In this paper, we examine the robustness of both traditional automatic metrics and the LLM-as-a-judge approach for assessing the quality of financial commentaries in Portuguese, an underexplored task and language that has been neglected in previous work. We introduce fine-grained perturbations into the texts generated by specialists to analyze which types of noise most significantly affect evaluation outcomes, using noise-free counterparts as references. The results highlight the weaknesses of classical metrics in this specific task and the limitations of even recent evaluation paradigms, underscoring the need to develop context- and domain-sensitive.

Material facts (MF) are crucial and obligatory disclosures that can significantly influence asset values. Following their release, financial analysts embark on the meticulous and highly specialized task of crafting analyses to shed light on their impact on company assets, a challenge elevated by the daily amount of MFs released. Generative AI, with its demonstrated power of crafting coherent text, emerges as a promising solution to this task. However, while these analyses must incorporate the MF, they must also transcend it, enhancing it with vital background information, valuable and grounded recommendations, prospects, potential risks, and their underlying reasoning. In this paper, we approach this task as an instance of controllable text generation, aiming to ensure adherence to the MF and other pivotal attributes as control elements. We first explore language models’ capacity to manage this task by embedding those elements into prompts and engaging popular chatbots. A bilingual proof of concept underscores both the potential and the challenges of applying generative AI techniques to this task.