Dungeons & Dragons (D&D) is a classic tabletop game with a 50-year history. Its intricate and customizable gameplay allows players to create endless worlds and stories. Due to the highly narrative component of this game, D&D and many other interactive games represent a challenging setting for the Natural Language Generation (NLG) capabilities of LLMs. This paper explores using LLMs to generate new spells, which are one of the most captivating aspects of D&D gameplay. Due to the scarcity of resources available for such a specific task, we build a dataset of 3,259 instances by combining official and fan-made D&D spells. We considered several LLMs in generating spells, which underwent a quantitative and qualitative evaluation. Metrics including Bleu and BertScore were computed for quantitative assessments. Subsequently, we also conducted an in-vivo evaluation with a survey involving D&D players, which could assess the quality of the generated spells as well as their adherence to the rules. Furthermore, the paper emphasizes the open-sourcing of all models, datasets, and findings, aiming to catalyze further research on this topic.