Training a language model for low-resource languages is challenging due to data scarcity and computational cost. Tokenizer transfer offers a way to adapt a pre-trained model to a new tokenizer without full retraining, improving efficiency and cross-lingual applicability. To the best our of knowledge, we present the first controlled evaluation of tokenizer transfer on monolingually pretrained base models trained on language-specific corpora, Orthogonal Mapping Pursuit (OMP) and Fast Vocabulary Transfer (FVT), across six languages and multiple finetuning regimes. Using the Goldfish model family, we evaluate using byte-normalized log-perplexity and MultiBlimp accuracy for target-language adaptability, source-language retention, and the interaction between transfer and monolingual or mixed finetuning. OMP with monolingual target finetuning yields the best target-language scores (lower log-perplexity and higher MultiBlimp) among our evaluated conditions, compared with (i) a model trained only on the source language, (ii) a model trained on a smaller amount of target-language data, and (iii) the source language model adapted via standard finetuning on the target data. The results suggest tokenizer transfer is a compute-efficient alternative for low-resource LM training: train a monolingual tokenizer for the target language, transfer it to a larger pre-trained model, and fine-tune using the target data.