Jieqiong Ding

Author directory

2026

Clinical NLP increasingly relies on electronic health record (EHR) data to detect suicidal behaviors, treating clinical documentation as more reliable ground truth than social media. We argue that this framing obscures how EHR-based suicidality datasets encode a particular operationalization of suicidality, shaped by who authors the data,how episodes are bounded, and how ambiguity is resolved. We ground this argument in a case study of the ScAN dataset, built over MIMIC-III clinical notes. We show how governance constraints, ICD-based cohort selection, single-annotator labeling, and hospital-stay-level aggregation produce labels that foreground clinician judgment, treat suicidality as a bounded episode, andassume that intent can be reliably inferred from documentation. A linguistic analysis demonstrates that identical labels subsume heterogeneous clinical framings differing in temporality, negation,and uncertainty, and that labeling patterns differ across insurance status. We argue the clinical NLP community should examine the assumptions embedded in suicidality datasets before interpretingtheir labels as ground truth.