Although large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable performance, the inherent stochasticity of their reasoning processes and varying conclusions present significant challenges. Majority voting or Best-of-N with external verifiers has been explored to mitigate this, but these approaches are limited in applicability or require additional training. To address this problem, we propose a novel framework that Recycles Few-shot examples to verify LLM outputs (ReFeri). Our key idea is to utilize the given few-shot examples not only to generate outputs, but also to evaluate the candidate outputs. Specifically, ReFeri combines a forward confidence score with a backward reconstruction penalty to select candidates that follow few-shot guidance while avoiding demonstration-specific overfitting. Experiments with three different LLMs across seven diverse tasks demonstrate that our framework significantly improves the accuracy of LLMs—achieving an average relative gain of 8.2%—through effective response selection.