Zhaojun Ding
Author directory2026
SCOPE: Stepwise Calibration of Reasoning Confidence with Outcome-Grounded Prefix Evidence
Huaqin Zhao | Yifan Zhou | Bolun Sun | Chao Cao | Yiwei Li | Zhaojun Ding | Lu Zhang | Tianming Liu | Jin Lu
Proceedings of the 2026 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing
Huaqin Zhao | Yifan Zhou | Bolun Sun | Chao Cao | Yiwei Li | Zhaojun Ding | Lu Zhang | Tianming Liu | Jin Lu
Proceedings of the 2026 Conference on Empirical Methods in Natural Language Processing
Reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards (RLVR) improves language-model reasoning using outcome-level supervision, but this supervision is temporally coarse: it indicates whether a trajectory ends with a correct answer, without revealing when the reasoning becomes reliable or silently fails. Existing verbalized-confidence methods typically calibrate a single confidence score after the final answer, leaving intermediate uncertainty unobserved. We propose SCOPE (Stepwise Calibration with Outcome-grounded Prefix Evidence), which trains reasoning models to emit confidence after each reasoning step. SCOPE interprets step confidence as the model’s prefix-conditioned belief in the gold answer: how likely the gold answer is under the reasoning prefix generated so far. During training, SCOPE constructs a soft target by scoring the gold answer conditioned on each reasoning prefix under the current policy. It then distills this signal with a two-stage masked RL objective: the first stage stabilizes the output format and final-answer accuracy, while the second stage performs calibration-only masked updates by applying stepwise and final-confidence rewards only to the numerical tokens inside the emitted confidence spans. Experiments on mathematical reasoning benchmarks show that SCOPE improves stepwise and final-confidence calibration while preserving final-answer reasoning performance. We further show that the resulting confidence signals support downstream inference-time control, enabling more reliable Learn-Then-Test risk control and stronger confidence-weighted aggregation.