We propose a novel automatic evaluation metric for open-ended text generation, which is a substantial improvement of the recently developed method, Fourier analysis of cross-entropy (FACE), hence, FACE-2. FACE-2 is a psycholinguistically inspired metric that extracts the dynamic patterns (spectrum) of text surprisal. Examined with open-ended text generation tasks, FACE-2 significantly outperforms a broad set of baseline metrics in revealing the model scaling effect, which scales up to models of 70B parameters, while many other existing metrics fail to capture this effect. We have also confirmed the advantage of FACE-2 in producing stronger agreement with human preferences from a large human-annotated dataset. We advocate for including metrics that mine the dynamics of likelihood in evaluating open-ended text generation, which covers broader aspects of human language than only using static likelihood-based or semantic-based metrics. Code repository: https://github.com/CLCS-SUSTech/FACEScore.

Human and model-generated texts can be distinguished by examining the magnitude of likelihood in language. However, it is becoming increasingly difficult as language model’s capabilities of generating human-like texts keep evolving. This study provides a new perspective by using the relative likelihood values instead of absolute ones, and extracting useful features from the spectrum-view of likelihood for the human-model text detection task. We propose a detection procedure with two classification methods, supervised and heuristic-based, respectively, which results in competitive performances with previous zero-shot detection methods and a new state-of-the-art on short-text detection. Our method can also reveal subtle differences between human and model languages, which find theoretical roots in psycholinguistics studies.