Motifs are distinctive, recurring, widely used idiom-like words or phrases, often originating in folklore and usually strongly anchored to a particular cultural or national group. Motifs are significant communicative devices across a wide range of media—including news, literature, and propaganda—because they can concisely imply a large set of culturally relevant associations. One difficulty of understanding motifs is that their meaning is usually implicit, so for an out-group person the meaning is inaccessible. We present the Motif Implicit Meaning Extractor (MIME), a proof-of-concept system designed to automatically identify a motif’s implicit meaning, as evidenced by textual uses of the motif across a large set data. MIME uses several sources (including motif indices, Wikipedia pages on the motifs, explicit explanations of motifs from in-group informants, and news/social media posts where the motif is used) and can generate a structured report of information about a motif understandable to an out-group person. In addition to a variety of examples and information drawn from structured sources, the report includes implicit information about a motif such as the type of reference (e.g., a person, an organization, etc.), it’s general connotation (strongly negative, slightly negative, neutral, etc.), and it’s associations (typically adjectives). We describe how MIME works and demonstrate its operation on a small set of manually curated motifs. We perform a qualitative evaluation of the output, and assess the difficulty of the problem, showing that explicit motif information provided by cultural informants is critical to high quality output, although mining motif usages in news and social media provides useful additional depth. A system such as MIME, appropriately scaled up, would potentially be quite useful to an out-group person trying to understand in-group usages of motifs, and has wide potential applications in domains such as literary criticism, cultural heritage, marketed and branding, and intelligence analysis.